Photo: Imagn Images

The diversity of leagues is one aspect that makes fantasy football so much fun. Some people like the larger leagues, while some like the smaller ones. The value of respective players varies widely with the differences in scoring and starting lineup. It is not advisable to use standard draft strategies in the non-standard leagues. This is especially true with leagues which offer the ability to insert two quarterbacks in the starting lineup. These “Superflex” leagues add another layer to regular one- or two-quarterback leagues. An owner may use the flex position in the starting lineup to start a quarterback, running back, wide receiver, or tight end. An entirely different strategy is essential to make the most of the draft. This article will look at 10-team leagues, starting one quarterback with the option to start another in the flex, and utilizing PPR scoring. We will examine strategies specially designed for these leagues in order to best attack the draft and get the most for your roster. These will help you form a new strategy for your league.

Down to basics

What are the differences I should know about the Superflex leagues?

a. The biggest question is how to value quarterbacks in comparison to other positions. In leagues that allow any of the skill positions at the flex, even the most average quarterbacks are worth as much as good running backs and receivers. It is difficult to balance gaining studs at other positions while still addressing quarterback. A team with two strong quarterbacks has a distinct advantage. As a general rule, it is best to only draft elite players at running back or wide receiver over starting quarterbacks. So, this means you should only take the top four or five running backs (e.g., Saquon Barkley, Alvin, Kamara, etc.) or the top few wideouts (e.g., DeAndre Hopkins, Julio Jones, Michael Thomas, etc.) over the quarterback position in the first two rounds. Even then, a quarterback might be the best option. The depth at the quarterback position will make it easier to take running backs and receivers in the early rounds. George Kittle is the lone tight end worthy of consideration early in fantasy drafts. The VBD values will show balance in value (VBD) between positions. But, your leaguemates will be taking passers early and often. You have a choice to either follow the crowd or eschew quarterback for value elsewhere and hope to land to low-end starters later. There is little middle ground. In one-quarterback leagues, the quarterback position is devalued tremendously due to so many viable players at the position. In Superflex leagues, there is a balance. This balance creates choices. The VBD points to your ability to wit on the quarterback position. But you must make the decision as there is no middle ground, either grab a pair of quarterbacks early or wait for one or more in the later rounds.

b. How do I know which quarterbacks to select? The main difference with Superflex leagues is the increase in value with the players from QB8 to QB19. The top few quarterbacks retain good value in all leagues, but it is the ones ranked lower that need the extra analysis. The players in this range (QB8-QB19) are ranked lower because there is a question about talent, the certainty of the situation, potential lack of upside, or just lack of proven production. Fantasy owners usually struggle with differentiating between less-than-stellar options. Roughly one projected point per game separates QB8 (Jared Goff) from QB19 (Josh Allen). If we stretch the range from QB8 (Goff) to QB24 (Matthew Stafford), the projected scoring is approximately two-and-a-half points per contest. With so many alternatives, the priority should be on seeking value. While it sounds simplistic, select the players who are the most talented. Next, do not spend a pick before the seventh or eighth round on a player whose job is not secure. Since every team in your league hopes to start two players at the quarterback position, finding options with upside and proven production is the key to gaining value. The close expected production between Goff and Allen could lead you to consider passing on quarterbacks until 10 or so are off the board. If this is your plan, target Roethlisberger or Brees to anchor the group and take a chance on Winston or Prescott later.

c. How does the quarterback scarcity impact the early rounds? There will be quarterback runs. This is inevitable. In leagues which enable starting two players at the quarterback position, owners will see the runs coming and will be desperate not to be left behind. This is all driven by positional scarcity. For this reason, we advocate either selecting a stud quarterback, or two, early just to stay ahead of the curve or waiting and selecting value early and scooping up running backs and wide receivers. The main rationale for going quarterback early is the mad rush for passers will push quality players at other positions down the draft.

When we look at the VBD (Value-Based Drafting) application, we quickly realize how a Superflex starting lineup balances out the options in the early rounds. The VBD accounts for positional scarcity and available options at other positions using the Footballguys.com projections.

Here are the league variables:

• 10 teams
• 16 roster spots
• PPR scoring

And here are the starting requirements:

• 1 Quarterback
• 2 Running Backs
• 3 Wide Receivers
• 1 Tight End
• 1 Flex (RB, WR, or TE)
• 1 Kicker
• 1 Team Defense

It is amazing that in the first 36 players listed in terms of value, just 2 are quarterbacks, 15 running backs, 16 wide receivers, and 3 tight ends. The balance is incredible in what represents the first three-plus rounds of a fantasy draft.

Below are the Top 50 players according to the VBD values:

It is interesting how the positions are balanced, even with being a league where two quarterbacks may be started. Yes, there are 4 are quarterbacks, 21 running backs, 21 wide receivers, and 4 tight ends. ... all with values in the first five rounds. Talk about symmetry. As far as draft strategy, the values indicate a push to get as many of the top quarterbacks as possible, or wait at the position, add running backs early in the draft before they become scarce. With the emphasis on quarterbacks early, many solid running backs and wide receivers will be pushed down the draft and become value picks. How does it change for the players 51-90? This represents the first half of the draft.

The wide receivers and running backs are still balanced, actually even until player 60 (Allen Robinson). With merely 14 quarterbacks off the board, it means most teams still have just one passer at the position. The balance between positions has pushed very good backs and receivers into extreme value situations. Players like Marvin Jones, Larry Fitzgerald, and even A.J. Green did not make the Top 90. Each is a steal this late.

After running a few mocks, it became obvious that developing a plan for the quarterback position is essential. There is no way to win your league if you are starting Andy Dalton and Joe Flacco at the quarterback position. A team rostering two of the top eight elite fantasy options has a monstrous advantage. A shortage is quickly created. But, a solid case may be made to load up on the running back position early, sprinkle in receivers, then grab three quarterbacks after the first ten are off the board, is a viable plan. The wide receiver position is the opposite. The are several very good options available at wide receiver in the middle of the draft.

In Superflex leagues, the tight end position becomes less valuable relative to the other positions. Savvy owners should wait until the eighth round or later to address the position. There are more than ten quality tight ends, so you can afford to wait.

Please feel free to email me (Tefertiller@Footballguys.com) with any questions or comments. Also, I am on Twitter (www.Twitter.com/JeffTefertiller), and LinkedIN, so feel free to connect where most convenient.